How do you feel about TBS’s postseason coverage?
Paddy says…I think that TBS has done a bad enough job that MLB should find a new network to broadcast their postseason games next season. This is, of course, impossible due to broadcast contracts, but the fact of the matter is that TBS has become as much of a story as the baseball itself because of their poor presentation. Between the coverage errors, poor announcing, and ceaseless George Lopez advertising, TBS has come under so much (not undeserved) fire that the great baseball that they’ve been showing has been overshadowed – and, particularly in the playoffs, that’s just unacceptable.
Charlie says…TBS has done a nice job with its Division Series coverage. From an audio/video perspective, the picture is clear and the crowd noise/field of play sounds are good. As far as the announcers go, just about anyone not named Tim McCarver, Joe Morgan or Steve Phillips is about all I can ask for. I will say one thing though: I hate the instant “Pitchtrax” in the lower right corner of the screen during at bats. At fist I thought it was an interesting concept, to show pitch location in relation to the strike-zone instantly, but it takes away the age old banter, “THAT WAS A STRIKE!! WHAT’S THAT UMP LOOKING AT!!” Pitchtrax shows you instantly ball or strike instantly, which ends the argument and takes away some of the fun of watching a ballgame on T.V.
Robert says…Baseball is a difficult sport to televise so I’m inclined to give the networks the benefit of the doubt in most cases. I don’t think TBS is doing a terrible job but they’re not setting a new bar in broadcasting excellence either. I’m just glad we don’t have to listen to Tim McCarver for another week or so.
Jonathan says…I’m lukewarm to TBS’ playoff coverage. I like PitchTrax and seeing the Division Series in one place. But their scheduling hasn’t been kind to Philadelphia, which makes it tough for me to watch. The broadcast teams are poor at best and feel hastily thrown together. Maybe TBS can use local broadcast teams next season.
I haven’t watched much of the in-studio coverage, but Ernie Johnson is great. Baseball is not his specialty, but he does a phenomenal job covering it. TBS’ advertising is horrible and overplayed. At least we avoid Joe Buck and Tim McCarver for the time being.
Zach says...Not real happy with it. Chip Caray is aweful, and doesn’t seem like he knows any other words than “fisted”. I think that MLB needs to find some way out of the contract they have with them, or at least force them to stop showing George Lopez every commercial break. It’s never good when people want more of Buck/McCarver.
Daniel says…I’ve only unmuted the coverage for a little while so I don’t know if I’m qualified to speak on TBS’s coverage. For the time that I did listen to the announcing it wasn’t very good, and I’m not a big fan of the pitch location box they keep in the corner throughout at bats. Watching the reactions to the announcing on Twitter was quite amusing though, as #fisted became a popular phrase and various other poor calls turned into memes. So I assume that some other people didn’t think highly of the coverage either.